The Good, The Bad And The Ugly [Il buono, il brutto, il cattivo] (1966)

Somehow, Angel Eyes Returned

***This Review Contains Spoilers***

Has there ever been a cinematic experience more visceral than The Good, The Bad And The Ugly? It’s a tall order to describe watching a film as a spiritual experience, but Sergio Leone’s spaghetti western masterpiece is the closest I feel I can get to one. Although I am not a western aficionado, allow me to try to articulate as to why The Good, The Bad And The Ugly (Il buono, il brutto, il cattivo) is one of my 10 favourite movies of all time.

The Good, The Bad And The Ugly is a film of sheer operatic, Lawrence of Arabia-like grandeur (something few other westerns have) in which the framing and intricate construction of just about every scene results in a 3-hour motion picture (if you choose the full-length version) which is over before you know it. I mean, the film’s treasure-hunt MacGuffin isn’t even established until 1 hour in, yet this in no way impedes its pacing. Moreover, the spaghetti western’s combination of the traditional western images as seen in Hollywood movies mixed with its own unique Mediterranean flavour (with its characters of southern European descent, Iberian and Roman Catholic imagery, and the presence of Mexican guitars and trumpets within the film score) in conjunction with the natural sounds (the howls of wind, the crunch of boots, sounds of coyotes, and just about every foley sound effect present), creates a cinematic experience which few other pictures in my years of film consumption have equalled.

You can take any scene from The Good, The Bad And The Ugly to deconstruct and dissect their multiple layers to understand what makes them so compelling. Take the scene in which the character of Tuco (Eli Wallach) is speaking to the dying soldier Bill Carson (Antonio Casale). This is a scene in which a character delivers lengthy expository dialogue (a death sentence to any film if not handled in a constructive or clever manner). The scene itself succeeds in drawing suspense from having a character on the edge of death delivering important information, and just like Tuco, as a viewer, you are in a state of tension as to whether or not he will reveal the location of a Confederate gold stash before biting the dust. However, the other layer which makes the scene compelling is about what is happening off-screen. Before the interaction with Carson, Tuco was allowing his nemesis Blondie (Clint Eastwood) to slowly die in the desert sun, so what has become of him outside the frame? It’s multiple layers like these that have your brain running multiple cylinders of engagement.

Correspondingly, one particular favourite scene of mine is that with Tuco in the gun store. The sequence plays out with such immaculate grace and rhythm; I get the same feeling as I would watching a Fred Astaire dance number. Reportedly, Wallach’s use of the firearms in the scene was improvised, although I’m at the point in my years of film analysis that I take any claim of “this scene/moment was improvised” with a grain of salt. Regardless, it does convincingly show that Tuco is a technician in his craft as he effortlessly tries different combinations of firearms with such satisfying grace and poise. While I do ask the question of why a gun store does not have any security protocols, a lot of suspense is drawn from the unpredictability of where the scene is going, and ultimately whether or not Tuco is going to take the life of the bemused and meek store owner. Likewise, I can’t help but detect a Terminator influence when Tuco takes the hat at the end.

Sergio Leone is also the master of the tight close-up, showing every facial detail of his subjects.  All the men in Leone’s work, even if they only appear in a single scene, have beat-up faces which show that these are men who have lived rough lives, from the hang dogs of the gentleman who gets assassinated in the beginning to the meek and bemused gun store owner. That said, if there is a single shot which I feel best represents Leone’s cinematic artistry, it is that of Blondie falling down the sand dune. I almost can’t comprehend how much planning and coordination must have gone into this shot. Firstly, the sand in the shot must have been untouched prior to filming, while the sun, which appears just above the frame with its rays coming through, had to have been in the right part of the sky. Then, Eli Wallach is in frame standing atop the sand dune while Clint Eastwood is rolling down the dune towards the camera, which he must perform in a convincing manner. All of this is impressive in itself, but what really elevates the shot is Wallach throwing a glass bottle onto the ground, which then rolls down the dune (never leaving the frame) towards Eastwood and hits him on the head. The perfectly timed gravity of that alone has me in awe.

With all that said, what is a movie without characters, and if there is one character who owns The Good, The Bad And The Ugly, it is the Ugly himself, Eli Wallach, portraying the legend that is Tuco Benedicto Pacífico Juan María Ramírez. One of my choices for the 10 greatest screen performances of all time, Tuco is one of cinema’s most entertainingly shameless characters. An Eric Cartman-like figure who will pull a 180 without blinking when the opportunity suits him. Tuco is the polar-opposite of the cool, laid-back and stoic Blondie. He is a cranky, ever-vocal, profanity-spewing, full-of-life, carnivalesque character. Yet despite his horrible deeds (including those he is alleged to have committed in the past), as a viewer, I can’t help but be endeared to Tuco. He is childlike at times; while co-stars Blondie and Angel Eyes are like the grown-ups in the room, Tuco is often naïve and innocent, believing what other people tell him. Take the moment at the prisoner-of-war camp in which he actually believes that “good treatment” means good treatment. Like many great characters of cinema, it’s all the little things which add up to really enhance a character, from his carrying of a pink parasol (why does he have a parasol when he’s already wearing a sombrero?), using bath salts, to often referring to himself in the third person.

Moreover, Tuco is the only character in the film to be given a backstory, as he shares the classic Angels With Dirty Faces dynamic with his brother. One chose the priesthood, the other chose a life of crime (although Tuco still blesses himself over the dead, even if he takes the remaining money from their wallets). Like the character of El Indio in For a Few Dollars More, the handful of times Leone’s films include character backstories, they always go down hard. Although Clint Eastwood may be top billed in The Good, The Bad And The Ugly, Tuco not only steals the show; he actually has the most screen time of the film’s cast members.

When watching the films of The Dollars Trilogy, I’m always taken aback by the high-level street smarts present in many of the characters. Their ability to stay alert and ahead of the game feels like a superpower or an act of magic (personally, I am also impressed that these characters can remember information over such a long period of time without writing it down). This is no better representation of this than the scene in which the bounty hunter Elam (Al Mulock) attempts to capture Tuco, only to be shot and killed by Tuco, hiding a gun out of sight in his lather-filled bathtub, followed by the line “If you have to shoot, shoot, don’t talk” (ignored by every movie villain ever) and, subsequently, possibly the first sideways gun shot in film history? However, it’s Clint Eastwood as Blondie as the character who best represents this with his effortless and, at times, hair-raising stoicism. Like the other entries in The Dollars Trilogy, Blondie is a man of few words and few theatrical expressions, yet you always know what is on his mind (the yin to Tuco’s yang). Yet, even a figure like Blondie can develop a subtle bond with Tuco (despite Tuco’s attempt to slowly kill him in the desert), as memorably seen when Blondie asks Angel Eyes about Tuco’s fate, with a tiny hint of genuine concern.

Blondie’s defining scene, playing into his role as The Good, is his encounter with the dying soldier towards the picture’s conclusion. I find this to be the most moving moment in the film, in which Blondie gives the dying, shivering young Confederate his coat and tobacco to comfort him in his final living moments; a distillation of pure, raw human emotion (aided in no small part by Ennio Morricone’s incredible score). The soldier is then seen to pass away once the final breath of the cigar smoke comes out of his mouth, itself a reference to a scene in Jean-Luc Godard’s Breathless (A Bout De Souffle). This moment is a metamorphosis for Blondie, as he abandons his coat and starts wearing the poncho he wore in the other two Dollars pictures. On the historical timeline, The Good, The Bad And The Ugly takes place before A Fistful Of Dollars and For A Few Dollars More, but whether or not Eastwood is playing the same character in all three pictures, well, you can leave that to your own personal canonicity.

The spectre of death haunts the entirety of The Good, The Bad And The Ugly, from the bloodshed of the Civil War, the regular inclusion of nooses, to the finale in the cemetery. When watching a film like this, it’s difficult to comprehend that someone could so easily and casually kill another human being, yet, in this environment, men do it without flinching. The man, however, who embodies the spectre of death is Lee Van Cleef as the ice-cold and frighteningly intelligent (and ironically named) Angel Eyes. A man with the devil’s good looks and a pair of hawk eyes lining up his prey. During his introductory scene, the manner in which he says “Nice family” (I expect him to follow up with the words “Shame if something were to happen to them”), followed by his unrepentant killing of a minor, sends shivers down one’s spine. Even the manner in which Van Cleef walks (to make another comparison with said film) is very Terminator-like (reportedly this is due to a previous accident Van Cleef had). Dressed in black attire, Angel Eyes serves the role of a grim reaper-like figure. When Angel Eyes approaches you, you know your time has come.

During the sequence at the prisoner-of-war camp, it is established that Tuco and Angel Eyes have had previous contact in the past. Yet oddly, when Tuco first sees Angel Eyes at the camp, he asks, “Hey Blondie, isn’t that Angel Eyes?”, in a manner which indicates that Blondie also knows who Angel Eyes is even though the film hasn’t established that the two have had any prior contact. That said, coming back to film structure, when your picture is this immaculately constructed, you can get away with a certain amount of unexplained loose ends and coincidences. This is especially true if the film engages in effective and subtle forms of set-up and payoff. For example, early in the film, when Angel Eyes sees that Tuco is about to be hanged, he comments to an onlooker, “Even a filthy beggar like that has got a protecting angel… A golden-haired angel watches over him”. Later in the film, when the carriage full of dead Confederate soldiers arrives at Tuco and Blondie, is it just a conveniently timed coincidence or a case of divine intervention? When a film subtly establishes an idea, your brain is more likely to accept the less logical elements as the story progresses.

With these three main roles, the labels in the film’s title are not absolutes. The good is not entirely good, the bad is not entirely bad, and the ugly is not entirely ugly. Although to recontextualize the deeper meaning behind these three titular characters, for anyone who is aware of the final speech in the film Team America: World Police, in which the character of Gary explains three different types of people in the tapestry of humanity. If you know, you know. “There are two kinds of people in this world my friend”, perhaps make that three.

As the sound in Italian movies at the time was post-synchronised, the obvious dubbing remains the only big technical fault within The Good, The Bad And The Ugly, although once you get used to it, it does become part of the character and charm of spaghetti westerns. This does bring me to the one scene in the film which I do take issue with, albeit a scene which was deleted after the film’s 1966 Italian premiere, only to be restored for the 2003 extended English-language version of the film. The scene in question is that featuring Tuco meeting his gang in the cave. Unlike just about every other scene in the movie, the cinematography of the scene is quite poor, with a very flat image which lacks any depth. Likewise, with all due respect to Mr. Wallach, they shouldn’t have let him dub his own voice 36 years after the fact (the scene was not dubbed in English for its original 1967 English-language release), as his evidently aged voice, alongside the lack of any echo (or any foley sound of the on-screen fire), is very distracting. The scene does slow down the action, and not knowing where Tuco’s men came from when they are trying to capture Blondie doesn’t hurt the film’s verisimilitude.

Of the restored scenes in the full-length version, by far my favourite is that of Angel Eyes at the Confederate unit. The rotating shot which circles Angel Eyes to the trumpets of Ennio Morricone’s piece The Strong, is not only a stunning piece of cinematic mastery; the sequence is the one moment which gives Angel Eyes a small amount of humanity, as he looks on with sympathy at the horrors of war which surrounds him (the one time he has a look of concern on his face). The scene also serves to reduce Angel Eyes’ lengthy absence during the middle portion of the film. The other restored scenes in the extended cut are fine, but ultimately I feel that they don’t add nor take anything from the film. My perfect cut of The Good, The Bad And The Ugly would be the original American theatrical release with the inclusion of the scene of Angel Eyes at the Confederate unit.

Many will describe The Good, The Bad And The Ugly as a revisionist western, which, in many ways, it is, with its violence and other explicit content which would not have been featured in American westerns from years prior. That said, I really loathe this singular, cynical analysis that a film’s merits are attained by tearing down what came before it. The Good, The Bad And The Ugly is a film which shows much reverence for Hollywood cinema. Its scenes of the Civil War call back to both Gone With The Wind (1939) and The General (1926); the destruction of the bridge towards the film’s end is reminiscent of The Bridge On The River Kwai (1957), the gun shop scene calls back to similar scenes in the James Cagney movies The Public Enemy and Blonde Crazy (both 1931), while Tuco’s train stunt to free himself from his chains is right out of the Buster Keaton playbook. Likewise, I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention the film’s moments of comedy, from the white dust on the Union soldiers’ uniforms, Tuco’s absurdly long rap sheet to the Laurel & Hardy-like image of Tuco and Blondie carrying a box simply titled “explosives” on a stretcher. It might as well just say ACME; however, look closely at the boxes in the background of the aforementioned gun shop scene. What is that imprinted on them? “ACME: Extra Black Powder”. On the same note, 24 minutes into the film, the editing oddly employs a horizontal flip transition, the only instance in which the film uses a comical, non-conventional edit.

Yet, everything I have mentioned would be for nothing if not for the music, composed by the great Ennio Morricone. The music by Morricone is one of a handful of film scores I have repeatedly listened to in its entirety over the years (I even once had the pleasure of travelling through rural Spain while listening to the score). It’s a close call when it comes to choosing a favourite piece; however, I have to go with The Strong (Il Forte) (and its more divine counterpart, The Carriage of the Spirits (La Carrozza Dei Fantasmi)), a deeply emotional piece of music that feels fatalistic yet optimistic at the same time. Like much of Morricone’s work, many pieces in The Good, The Bad And The Ugly are like haunting lullabies; pieces such as The Mission of San Antonio (La Missione San Antonio) or The Story of a Soldier (La Storia De Un Soldato), I will listen to as I reminisce, sometimes with pain or heartache, other times just to quietly contemplate. Then, there is The Ecstasy of Gold (L’estasi dell’oro)…

One of the greatest movies of all time concludes with one of the greatest endings of all time. By what accounts we know off, the finale in the Sad Hill Cemetery (a set created for the film) was filmed with the music being composed beforehand to match the filmed actions, not just thrown on top as an afterthought, making it a sort of predecessor to the music video. When Tuco’s head hits a stone, we come to realise at the same time as the character that it was not just any stone, but a grave, in one of the best character realisations ever seen in a film. As Tuco joylessly throws a piece of paper away and starts frantically searching the cemetery for the grave of Arch Stanton and the $200,000 (equivalent to $6.68 million in 2026), there is a real sense of joy and catharsis. Yet there is an oddly fascinating juxtaposition between the almost religious intensity of the haunting, soaring choir in The Ecstasy of Gold and the rotating pov camera shots, with Tuco prancing around with his T-Rex arms. There is an extreme contrast between the greedy motivations of Tuco and the transcendental quality of the music, turning his pursuit into a moment of divine revelation and elevating him into a mythological figure.

It is moments like these that make the hairs rise on your body, which leave you unconsciously holding your breath and transfixed on the screen. It’s moments like these in which people can recall the exact circumstances of what was happening when they first saw it. I can. I was watching The Good, The Bad And The Ugly alone in my bedroom when my two friends turned up and we watched the last 20 or so minutes together. One of my friends then went onto YouTube to check the name of the piece of music over the famous scene. It’s moments like these which turn mere mortals into lifelong cinephiles.

No Regrets For Our Youth [わが青春に悔なし/Waga Seishun ni Kuinashi] (1946)

Those Who Make Tomorrow

***This Review Contains Spoilers***

During the postwar occupation of Japan from 1945-1952, Japanese films had to be approved by the American occupying forces. This brings about the great paradox regarding No Regrets For Our Youth (わが青春に悔なし/ Waga Seishun ni Kuinashi). How did American authorities approve a film that commemorates a leftist? The film is a clear disavowal of the Japanese military state (authoritarian, fascist, however you may want to describe it) that existed before the Japanese surrender (“The War is Lost, But Freedom is Restored“) and is big in its theme of the glorification of the individual, views far more in line with the American ideology. I can only speculate that the American authorities were willing to overlook the former because of the latter.

Despite its political backdrop (and even some of the overt imagery as seen in the third act), No Regrets For Our Youth has a much greater focus on being a deeply human story. Yukie Yagihara (Setsuko Hara), the daughter of a professor at Kyoto Imperial University, spends a sunny, peaceful day in 1933 with a group of the male alumni on the hills surrounding the city. As they are trying to cross a creek together, Yukie needs help at the end. The gawky and indecisive Itokawa (Akitake Kono) looks on without taking any action, while the confident Ryukichi Noge (Susumu Fujita) strides over to pick her up, much to the annoyance of the timid Itokawa, setting up the film’s love triangle. As they indulge in the whims of carefree youth, little do they know this is the calm before the storm, as gunshots suddenly rage from the university in protest against the suppression of academic freedom.

No Regrets For Our Youth is a film of modest means but largely succeeds in covering the 12-year period of time from 1933 to 1945. Even at this early stage in his career, director Akira Kurosawa’s work was displaying such dynamic use of the camera, especially during the aforementioned excursion to the hills (just how close is the camera to the river’s water in the film’s opening?). In his first post-war film, No Regrets For Our Youth is a massive leap for the director in comparison to his work during the war years (comparing No Regrets For Our Youth to The Most Beautiful from two years earlier is night & day in more ways than one). The film’s first act, however, is its weakest, relying quite heavily on some rather clunky montages to cover student protests at Kyoto Imperial University over academic freedom. Following this, however, the film quickly becomes deeply involving, thanks in no small part to an extraordinary performance by Setsuko Hara, in what is Kurosawa’s only film with a sole female protagonist.

Hara’s performance in No Regrets For Our Youth showcases why she is one of the greatest actresses to ever grace the silver screen. She has the ability to express profound emotion through the simplest gestures and convey so much and so precisely without words. The strongest demonstration of this (and my favourite scene in the movie), is when Yukie and Noge meet again for the first time in years in his Tokyo office. The intensely claustrophobic scene runs seven minutes in length, as Yukie and Noge converse in the empty office building about the nostalgic days of old. With its westernised office setting and intense, drenched shadows, the scene is visually reminiscent of a Hollywood production, with Hara’s striking facial expressions being imprinted onto your psyche, creating a scene I was deeply moved by.

The journey which Yukie takes over the course of the film is what would now be referred to as “finding yourself” (but not in a ridiculous, cliché manner in which someone travels to an eastern land to meet a monk in a cave to gain otherworldly knowledge). This is established through the film’s love triangle between Yukie and polar opposites of the virgin Itokawa and the chad Noge. Yukie is drawn to Noge and his dangerous yet thrilling life as a social activist on the edge of society. On the other hand, she can choose the meek and mild-mannered Itokawa, a man of the system who goes with the flow. Life with him would be stable, safe, but ultimately boring. Noge is not afraid to tell Yukie off and reprimand her for her political illiteracy (“He’s just telling the truth, something you are incapable of doing”) following her professor father (Denjirō Ōkōchi) losing his position due to his opposition to the Japanese invasion of Manchuria. Following this (and to further hammer the difference between these two men), out of frustration with Noge’s comments, Yukie asks Itokawa to kneel down, to which he obliges, only to then tell him to stop and asks, “What are you doing!?”.

There are indications throughout the early portion of the story that only does Yukie desire a life of excitement but that she also doesn’t fit in with conventional society. In the aforementioned opening scene on the hills surrounding the university, Yukie actually becomes excited by the sounds of the gunshots (“It’s so clear and rhythmic. It makes my heart race!”. Likewise, her mother mentions that in elementary school, she only drew things like aeroplanes and locomotives, suggesting her non-conformist streak outside of traditionally expected roles. Later, to her mother’s approval, Yukie takes up flower arranging; however, she feels that none of her arrangements truly represent how she feels. In one class, frustrated, she disassembles her work and proceeds to throw three petals into a bowl, representing herself, Noge and Itokawa. Additionally, a very strange moment worth mentioning is the editing when Yukie enters a room to get away from her mother while in a state of despair; she stands by the door as 5 different fade-in shots occur over the same frame. Initially, I presumed this was to convey the passing of time, but then the mother is still there on the other side, as if she has been standing there for a comically long period of time.

Yukie later moves to Tokyo, where she meets Noge once again, and the two start a relationship. The character of Noge himself was inspired by the real-life case of Hotzumi Ozaki, the only Japanese person to be hanged for treason against the Japanese state during World War II. The two lovebirds live together in domestic bliss; however, this is quickly cut short when Noge is arrested on charges of espionage. Noge dies in prison, although the film does not state how this happens (I can only guess that he got Epstein’d). Following Noge’s arrest and passing, Yukie becomes more politically enlightened about Japan’s oppressive state, although it could be argued her decisions seem tied more to her love for Noge than to any firm political belief. No Regrets For Our Youth does a very convincing job of showing Yukie’s ageing over the 12-year span. What is shocking, however, especially after becoming accustomed to seeing Hara as a goddess of domesticity in the Ozu films, is her brutalisation when she spends time in prison (also under espionage accusations) and, shortly after, her transformation into a hardened agrarian woman. After Yukie is bailed from prison, instead of returning to live with her parents, she finds the estranged parents of Noge in an unnamed rural village and asks to move in and assist them.

During this portion of the film, Yukie works in the fields, and it is filmed in the manner of a Soviet propaganda film, akin to the works of Alexander Dovzhenko. Just as Soviet cinema shows upward shots of giant figures working the earth, No Regrets For Our Youth employs this same style to give Yukie a heroic stature. Yet despite the cinematographic influence, this portion of the film (even more significantly than the rest of the picture) is about defiance against the collective, with Kurosawa glorifying the individual characters, not the farmers as a collective. Noge’s parents have been ostracised by the rest of the village due to their son’s political activities, with their home being covered in graffiti denouncing them as a house of spies. As a result, Yukie and Noge’s mother (Haruko Sugimura) only work the fields at night, until Yukie defies the onlooking villagers and chooses to work during the day, to the point of physical exhaustion and sickness (in Soviet Russia, you don’t work field, field works you).

“The War is Lost, But Freedom is Restored“, states a title card as the story wraps up in a newly American-occupied Japan. Yukie’s father has his position as professor at the university restored, and the late Noge is venerated. While it feels like things have come full circle back to those peaceful, innocent days on the hills outside Kyoto back in 1933, Yukie is no longer the girl she was back then. The film concludes with Yukie hitching a ride on the back of a truck to participate in an organisation called the Rural Cultural Movement, as a defiant Yukie chooses her own path. No Regrets For Our Youth doesn’t state a reason why Yukie chose to undergo the intense hardship in the village, but I believe it’s not difficult to identify her reasons for doing so: trying to uphold the memory of a lost lover, guilt over a misspent youth, or not having been more active in political movements. Above all, however, I believe this is what was required for Yukie to undergo a metamorphosis, to achieve a quiet, indomitable pride and ultimately to free herself from having no regrets for her youth.

The Doll [Die Puppe] (1919)

Weird Science

***This Review Contains Spoilers***

The Doll (Die Puppe) showcases that the early days of cinema were capable of producing a high-concept oddity such as this. A film which can be sold in a one-line summary: “A man forced into marriage by his uncle decides to fool him by marrying a life-like mechanical doll instead” – “Yeah, I want to watch that!”

The Doll is an early example of a film using a metaphysical framing device. Director Ernst Lubitsch himself opens the picture by pulling pieces from a small chest to build a diorama in front of the audience. It’s not only a clever framing device but also acts like a commentary on the role of a director, as this diorama comes to life and proceeds to tell the story. All throughout the film, the sets, the backdrops and the props look like they belong in a doll’s house (while at the same time feeling distinctly Germanic). Kitchen utensils are simply drawings painted on walls, paper clouds part way to reveal a happy sun, while the moon echoes back to the iconic image of the celestial body in Georges Méliès’’ A Trip to the Moon (1902). Even the animals too are phoney; the cockerel is an animated drawing, the cat is a moving silhouette, and most memorably of all, the horses which draw a carriage, make no attempt to disguise the fact that they are men in horse costumes.

Lancelot (Hermann Thimig) is ordered by his uncle, the Baron of Chanterelle (Max Kronert), to get married on July 28th 1778. The weak and effete man, however, has an aversion to marriage, literally crying when told that he must tie the knot. In order to abdicate his responsibility, he hides out and takes refuge in an abbey following a Scooby-Doo-like chase by an army of maidens (is the film trying to comment on the reasons why men end up joining the clergy, to escape women through religion?). The monks of the abbey, however, propose a solution to his problem: marry a mechanical doll and fool people into thinking it is your wife.

A dollmaker, Hilarius (Victor Janson), has created a mechanical doll based on his own daughter Ossi (Ossi Oswalda), which will then be sold to another man (itself somewhat unsettling, but I digress). His lineup of dolls appears to be fully reminiscent of flesh-and-blood human women; thus I can only imagine what men may be choosing to do with these contraptions – “Available for bachelors, widows and misogynists”, proclaims an advertisement. The dolls, as they are referred to throughout the film, would most closely be classified as life-sized mechanical automatons, designed to imitate human actions through an internal mechanism (which requires oiling twice per week according to the creator). Although the film doesn’t rule out whether these dolls are sentient in any way, the premise of men being able to buy automated, life-like dolls who fulfil a fantasy role and make no demands, I can’t help but make the comparison to the age of AI companionship.

Just before the sale, the doll is accidentally broken, to which Ossi pretends to be the doll until it can be repaired. The Doll is an early cinematic example of classic mistaken identity comedy, enhanced by the cartoon logic of its universe in that no one seems to strongly question the peculiar nature of this woman despite her odd and erratic behaviour. Oswalda excels in the role of a woman pretending to be an automaton with her back-and-forth between rigidity and sudden exuberance, with the film taking full advantage of the comic pratfalls this premise has to offer. Although if there is one character who steals the show with his comically timed, mature-for-his-age womanising, it’s the apprentice of the dollmaker (Gerhard Ritterband). The dollmaker and his young apprentice share a peculiar father-son-like relationship, as seen when the apprentice tries to imitate his boss’s mannerisms in real-time unison.

When Lancelot eventually discovers his doll is actually a real girl, this fairy-tale-like story has analogies to the story of Pinocchio, both in the theme of telling lies and in the way his doll became a real girl once he discovered the truth of the situation. “I want a proper doll of solid character”, said Lancelot to the dollmaker, to which his wish in the end came true.

The Last of the Mohicans (1920)

Before The West Was Won

***This Review Contains Spoilers***

Since most Western films take place within the time period of 1830 – 1890, it’s interesting to encounter examples set earlier in the history of the North American frontier, with The Last of the Mohicans (based on the novel of the same name by James Fenimore Cooper) being set during the French and Indian War (1754-1763). Although shot at San Bernardino National Forest and Yosemite National Park (both in California), the story itself takes place in modern-day Upstate New York. So can a film set that far east in the modern-day USA still classify as a western? I digress…

“The pale faces are our friends. Go to Fort Yonder and tell them of the danger that threatens.” The British stronghold of Fort Yonder will soon be under attack by French forces; thus, the women and children are to be evacuated to safer Fort Edward, with two of these women being Cora Munro (Barbara Bedford) and her younger sister Alice (Lillian Hall). The main emotional beat in The Last of the Mohicans is the forbidden interracial love between Cora and the Mohican warrior Uncas (Alan Roscoe). “Surely among his own people he is a prince”, utters Cora on her first sight of the striking warrior. The performances of the two stars are not dramatic; however, the film’s use of the classic Kuleshov effect helps create an eroticism which alongside their chemistry, as well as simply having a woman with a shirtless, well-toned man within a confined space, you can really feel the sexual tension between the two. Perhaps this chemistry however was not manufactured, as Bedford and Roscoe would go on to get married (twice, no less).

In stark contrast, however, to the princely, male beauty that is Uncas, is Cora’s fiancé, the cowardly Captain Randloph (George Hackathorne), who, memorably in one scene, tries to kiss Cora’s hand in front of Uncas only to get friend-zoned. Likewise, any Romeo & Juliet-style love story isn’t complete without the classic male love interest having a secret meeting at the lady’s window scene. Cora herself, however, is not denied her own heroism, sacrificing herself (on two occasions) to become the squaw of the villainous Magua in order to spare her sister. 

The ever larger-than-life Wallace Beery brings gravitas to the role of Magua, with his intimidating presence as he stands around flipping that knife. In the 1930s Beery became known for his pudgy appearance and lovable lug persona; however, this earlier Beery actually had an athletic build. Magua is introduced as “an Indian runner in service of the British”, but soon reveals his true colours, as a sympathiser for the French and the rival Huron tribe. The battle sequence in which Magua and the Hurons assault the British fort is rather D.W. Griffith-like. It also features the nightmarish image, in which one of the Huron men climbs into a broken stagecoach to pursue a woman and her baby. Through two pov shots, the Huron crawls towards the camera with his protruding eyes and knife in his mouth. He then grabs the woman’s baby from her arms and throws it into the air (to which I presume the baby meets its end). The Last of the Mohicans observes the Native Americans from a dignified perspective, with heroes and traitors being equally distributed between both the whites and the natives.

The Last of the Mohicans is a handsome production, although it’s not clear who directed which parts of the film between the two directors, Maurice Tourneur and Clarence Brown. Regardless, there are many stunning scenery shots captured in glorious depth of field, from the sun rising over a mountain to the striking use of silhouetted soldiers in trench coats or Indians against the sky. The film is also particularly keen on using cave entrances as a visual framing device, even capturing the rays of the sun entering the caves. Sadly, as of writing this review, the only copies of The Last of the Mohicans in circulation are beat-up, scratchy prints, and none accompanied by particularly great music scores. Hopefully, in the future, the film will get the boutique treatment.  

The film’s climax, with the untimely death of Cora and the subsequent final battle between Magua and Uncas, is exhilarating stuff – silent film melodrama at its finest. Taking place through a series of medium shots and long shots as the two men fight amongst epic vistas of towering cliff sides and raging waterfalls to metaphorically showcase the lust and the passion. The fight between the two warriors is a genuine brawl, featuring some impressive choreography between stuntmen topped with some intense tumbling down of steep hills. In the end, however, no one wins, with Magua himself succumbing to a fatal gunshot as his body falls down a waterfall. Get ready to see this trope repeated countless times for the next century. 

Spring, Summer, Fall, Winter… and Spring [봄 여름 가을 겨울 그리고 봄/Bom yeoreum gaeul gyeoul geurigo bom] (2003)

Remove The Stone Of Shame… Attach The Stone Of Triumph!

***This Review Contains Spoilers***

It is a cliché to describe a film as poetic, but Spring, Summer, Fall, Winter…and Spring is one instance in which I will do just that, as it is one of the most metaphorically and symbolically dense films I’ve ever seen. Although the picture is deeply rooted in Buddhist theology, the themes of the film transcend this into the realm of shared human experiences with concepts basic enough for anyone to understand. The most prominent of these (being baked right into its structure) is the cycle of life, which, as the title suggests, sees the movie tell its story over 5 vignettes, each taking place years apart and during one of the seasons of the year, before coming full circle once again. Likewise, the film is grounded in symbolising the significance of the number 4, from the aforementioned four seasons to the prominence of the four elements (earth, air, fire and water) to the most theologically significant for this picture, the Four Noble Truths in Buddhism. Although director Kim Ki-duk himself was a Christian, Spring, Summer, Fall, Winter…and Spring does feel like Everything You Always Wanted To Know About Buddhist Theology, *But Were Afraid To Ask.

Spring, Summer… takes place on a floating Buddhist hermitage on a lake surrounded by forests and mountains, in which an old unnamed monk (Oh Yeong-su) and his child apprentice (Jong-ho Kim) live out their days. The location itself is the Jusanji Pond in Cheongsong County, North Gyeongsang Province in South Korea, an artificial lake, although one with a mystical aura (reportedly, the film’s production company had to convince the South Korean Ministry of Environment through six months of negotiations to film at the location). Spring, Summer… begins as a pair of wooden doors on the lake open (acting like a pair of stage curtains), revealing this near-mythical world with its thick morning mist and striking reflections in the water (similar to the setting Ki-duk had previously explored in his film The Isle). Many of the film’s panoramic views of the lake are genuinely breathtaking, from the deep, intense reds and oranges of fall to the snow- and ice-covered landscapes of winter.

If media has taught me anything, it’s that if I travel into the wilderness of a far eastern land, I will meet a wise old man who will bestow me knowledge and wisdom far beyond my current puny understanding (the older monk in Spring, Summer… does have his share of Master Yoda-like lines; “Lust awakens the desire to possess. And that awakens the intent to murder”). During the first of the film’s vignettes, that taking place during spring, the older Monk delivers his first lesson. The child monk in his spare time finds pleasure in tying small animals to rocks and laughing so innocently at their pain (which itself is unsettling to watch). The older monk observes his actions and thus ties a large rock onto the boy’s back while he is sleeping, so that he may now carry a literal burden of guilt on his back. The older monk tells him he will only remove the rock once he has removed the rocks from the animals he tied up. 

Kim Ki-duk’s films are controversial for their on-screen depictions of animal cruelty. In Spring, Summer…, the torture of a frog, fish and snake is captured on screen. While I’m not going to pretend I’m bothered by this on a personal level, I will offer some mild criticism, as there is some clear hypocrisy on the part of the older monk (and the director too), as later in the film, the older monk performs calligraphy with a cat’s tail, to which the cat itself is clearly in pain. This is one aspect which I do find uncomfortable to watch, but there is also the fact that it comes after the older monk was criticising the boy for tying up the animals. Regardless, this doesn’t undo the power of the penance, as during the later winter vignette, the younger monk (now a man) chooses to undergo the same punishment. 

Concurrently, when the child monk takes the boat by himself across the lake to abuse the animals, the older monk later appears behind him on land to observe his behaviour. How did the older monk make his way to land, completely dry, when they only have one boat? The movie gives a potential answer to this, as during the fall vignette, when the younger monk, now an adult man, is being taken away by the authorities, the rowboat will not move at first despite the police officer attempting to row. It appears the older monk may have a supernatural pull on the boat, which may also offer an explanation as to who is opening the gates at the beginning of each vignette (with the exception of the fall vignette opening, in which it transitions to reveal the older monk is the one opening the gate). Spring, Summer… is an example of a film in which its lack of explanation enhances the dreamlike nature. Why is a young boy being raised by an older monk on a floating hermitage in the middle of nowhere? One possible explanation, which is supported by the film’s latter portion, is based on reported real-life cases of babies in the past being abandoned at churches and monasteries; however, the film doesn’t feel incomplete without these answers. Even the film’s place in time is left ambiguous, with the dress of the outsiders who visit the hermitage being only one of the few indications that the film takes place throughout the late 20th/early 21st century.

During the summer vignette, with the younger monk now a teenager, an unnamed young girl (Yeo-jin Ha) arrives at the hermitage to be cured of her illness. What is the illness? This is never explained. Only some vague comments, such as the girl’s mother (Kim Jeong-yeong) commenting to the boy, “You look so very healthy” and “This tree is over 300 years old. You will grow as healthy as this tree.” Assuming this is the younger monk’s first interaction with the opposite sex and that he would otherwise be living a life of celibacy, he develops a primal yet innocent interest in her, touching her body and not understanding boundaries. Primal is the key word here, as the relationship they develop is not a romantic one, but one of pure lust, in which the two eventually do make love. It is this portion of the film which brings to mind the Lady Eve in The Garden of Eden, as the girl’s presence upsets the natural order of things at the lake. For example, inside the hermitage, there is a door leading into a bedroom with no walls attached. My initial reaction was to find this comical, as it is a well-established visual gag in Western animation to feature a freestanding doorframe with no walls attached, yet characters still obey the “rules” of the doorway (another aspect which enhances the dreamlike nature of the film). However, with the presence of the girl, the younger monk comes to disregard the wall-less doorway; an abandonment of the restrictions governing his life.

Once the older monk finds the couple in the aftermath of another love-making session, he determines that the girl has been cured. He declares, “Then it was the right medicine”, although it’s not clear exactly what he is referring to. The younger monk, however, has been infected by modernity, as he leaves the hermitage to go and live a regular life, only to return in the fall vignette. The boy, now a devastated and unkempt man, returns to the lake on the run from the authorities after murdering his wife for adultery (it is not made clear, however, if the woman he murdered was the ill girl from summer). As penance for his crimes, the older monk has the man carve and then paint an extensive array of Chinese characters on wood. This does lead to one of the film’s more oddly endearing moments, in which the two plainclothes police officers sent to the hermitage to arrest the man (who had been disrespecting the sanctity of the site with their littering and gun target practice) end up joining in the calligraphy and take a genuine interest in it. Once the man has finally been taken away by the officers, the older monk chooses to end it all and commits self-immolation, as his eyes, ears and mouth are covered by the Chinese character for shut or close (閉). Why does he do it? It’s up to you, my dear friend, the viewer, to make your own interpretation. Regardless, the powerful and harrowing imagery is apt to showcase the closing of the reproductive cycle that autumn represents. 

In the winter vignette, the man, now older, returns to the abandoned and run-down hermitage to revitalise it. For the remainder of the film, the man is played by director Kim Ki-duk himself. According to the audio commentary on the Umbrella Blu-ray release, Ki-duk’s self-casting was a last-minute replacement, yet he performs the role remarkably well, especially with the physicality he displays. Many of his scenes involve him shirtless in sub-zero temperatures as he performs penance by once again carrying a giant rock on his back and performing a Korean Buddhist martial art known as Sunmudo (complete with some impressive mid-air kicks). 

During the winter rebuilding of the hermitage, a woman arrives with a baby to abandon, with such shame that she keeps her face covered (only for herself to fall into a hole in the ice). The man, now the new elder monk, must raise the child like his predecessor raised him. Much of the action present within Spring, Summer… may lead many viewers to find it a very cynical film on the human condition. Delight in torturing other living things, corruption of that which was pure, murder, disrespect for the sacred, abandonment of responsibility. During the film’s final vignette, …and Spring, the new young monk (played by the same young actor as the first young monk) is once again finding joy in torturing animals, this time by putting rocks in the mouth of a fish and a frog. That said, the film in no way leaves me feeling cynical. To come full circle myself to the Four Truths of Buddhism:

Spring (Childhood and Ignorance)

Summer (Adolescence and Desire)

Fall (Adulthood and Anguish)

Winter (Maturity and the Path)

…and Spring (Rebirth)

I’m by no means a theologian (“mention something out of a Charlton Heston movie and suddenly everybody is a theology scholar”), and while Spring, Summer, Fall, Winter…and Spring in many ways shows the cynical and destructive side of humanity, its spiritual structure shows that existence remains beautiful despite this. It is a cliché to describe a film as poetic, but Spring, Summer, Fall, Winter…and Spring is one instance in which I will do just that, as it is one of the most metaphorically and symbolically dense films I’ve ever seen…

The Isle [섬/Seom] (2000)

Hard to Swallow

***This Review Contains Spoilers***

*The following review contains descriptions of suicide, torture and animal cruelty.

The Isle features one of the more unique film settings I’ve ever encountered, taking place at a lake resort full of little floating platforms with huts placed atop, in which patrons rest, sleep and (and most significantly for this film) fish. I do find myself questioning the logic and safety implications of such a setup, yet it turns out such resorts do exist in South Korea known as Jwadae Naksi (좌대낚시), literally “platform fishing.” Information regarding these resorts is very limited in English (googling the romanised name yields no results), although this international obscurity makes the setting of The Isle all the more mysterious and dream-like (with director Kim Ki-duk employing a similar setting in his later film Spring, Summer, Autumn, Winter…and Spring). With this secluded setting and heavy emphasis on the surrounding nature, The Isle captures the introverted desire to be left alone. The opening scenes featuring the resort covered in a blanket of morning fog, with the aquatic-sounding music score, capture a sense of peace and tranquillity.

The resort in The Isle is operated by a mute, nameless woman (Suh Jung), although her name is credited as Hee-jin. The resort is very much her domain, in which she facilitates the men staying there with prostitutes and offers her own sexual services. Like other characters in Kim Ki-duk’s films, Hee-jin utters no dialogue throughout the entire film, yet so much is conveyed without it with her alluring yet threatening presence (as memorably captured on the film’s poster). There is a strong mythological element to her character, as she is comparable to the archetype of a nymph or the mould of a mermaid. Her attire of a long skirt mirrors that of a mermaid’s fin, while her seemingly supernatural ability to get out of the water and into a boat so fast or the recreation of the Captain Willard head rise out of the water echoes that of a mermaid (and with the water being her domain, this neatly ties alongside the symbolism of water as a representation of the feminine). Moreover, her role echoes that of Lady Wakasa in Ugetsu (1953) or the titular character in Woman In The Dunnes (1964), keeping the men as prisoners in her domain (early in the film, she even kills one of her patrons after he openly disrespects her following sexual services).

Hee-jin, however, does develop sympathy (and eventually falls for) one of her customers, a depressed, suicidal fugitive named Hyun-shik (Kim Yu-seok), who takes refuge at the resort to evade the authorities following a murder. He is, remarkably, the closest thing the resort has to a sympathetic male character (as sympathetic as you can get for someone who has murdered and attempted rape), compared to the other men who are all outright abusive and unpleasant. However, I have to say the film’s male lead is not terribly interesting (lacking the characterisation of his female co-star), and he does weaken the film overall. Although his character may be uninteresting, what he inflicts upon himself is anything but.

According to Roger Ebert in his review for The Isle, audience members gasped and walked out during the film’s screening at the Sundance Film Festival in 2001. The scene in question involves Hyun-shik quickly devising an impromptu way to kill himself (as he lost his gun earlier in a botched suicide attempt) when he sees that police have arrived at the resort to arrest him. So what is this way he is going to unalive himself? He gets a string of fishhooks, which he places inside his mouth and attempts to swallow, causing him to bleed profusely out of his mouth (possibly an ineffective way to kill yourself, but I guess when you’re about to be arrested by the police, you stop thinking rationally).

I’ve never been fishing, but I have handled hooks in the past, and they are something I feel squeamish about even touching, and I know I’m not alone in that thought, which I feel really makes this scene so difficult to watch without looking away from the screen. But it doesn’t end there (far from it). As Hee-jin arrives in the hut before the police, she hides Hyun-shik under the platform, dangling from a rod with the hooks still in his mouth. After the police leave, she then reels him back up with the rod like a literal fish (I can’t possibly think of a more graphic metaphor for the power dynamics between a man and woman). However, if this is not enough on-screen torture for you, Hee-jin later ups the ante with her own fishhook suicide attempt, only this time placing the hooks inside her vagina (bringing new meaning to the word hooker, amirite? *ba dum tiss!).

Following both of these suicide attempts, the opposite person removes the hooks from their respective body parts with pliers as they recover from the pain. I find both of these moments oddly satisfying to watch, as they represent a gradual relief after having endured the most unimaginable pain. Hee-jin even makes love to Hyun-shik after his own attempt as a way of easing the pain, which is soon followed by the ultimate consummation of their relationship in the film’s most oddly endearing scene of domesticity, as the two paint the floating hut bright yellow.

The Isle also includes several instances of animal cruelty. This includes the on-screen death of a frog, the electrocution of a fish and the slaughter of a fish (which is then returned to the lake in its mutilated form). Any Western perceptions on the reverence of certain animals over others are reflected in the fact that the Australian release I watched does feature one piece of censorship at 35:06 in which there is a visible cut in which a dog is pulled by the leash onto a boat, whereas the rest of the animal cruelty remained in this edition of the film. I hear many accounts that Kim Ki-Duk is not well regarded in his home country or among the South Korean filmmaking elite. I’d imagine this is due in part to the politically incorrect nature of his work, from the aforementioned treatment of animals to female characters who exist outside the progressive 21st-century norm (alongside accusations of assault made against the director). His work in my ways can be hard to swallow but is worth digesting, and that is a factor in why I find him to be the Korean filmmaker I’m most fascinated by.

The Swimming Pool [La Piscine] (1969)

Euromaxing

***This Review Contains Spoilers***

I bestow Jacques Deray’s The Swimming Pool (La Piscine) with the oddly specific accolade of being the 2nd best 1960s swimming pool-centric movie. The other film of this double feature I am referring to is Frank Perry’s The Swimmer (1968). Both movies not only share aesthetic similarities but also explore a seemingly idyllic existence that isn’t quite what it seems, with the use of swimming pools as a metaphor. A pool creates a refracted, warped image, and it’s only when seeing through the surface that things become clear.

The majority of The Swimming Pool takes place within the confines of a holiday villa in the French Riviera town of Saint-Tropez (which I am reliably informed is pronounced san troh-pay for us word ending consonant pronouncing English speakers). This setting makes The Swimming Pool an oxymoron of a film in that it is a thriller, yet a relaxing one at that. I find myself watching on in jealous enchantment as the sexy, shirtless and effortlessly cool Alain Delon and his glamorous, bronzed-fleshed co-star Romy Schneider flex their sculpted physiques as they relax and make love in the nostalgic, rustic, sun-soaked atmosphere (as 60’s lounge music along with the film’s repeated song of choice Ask Yourself Why sung by Ruth Price echo in the background). Jean-Paul Leroy (Delon) and his girlfriend of two years, Marianne (Schneider), are madly infatuated with each other as they intensely make out (back scratching and all) and engage in light-hearted power plays and one-upmanship. However, there is soon trouble in paradise with the unexpected arrival of the couple’s old friend Harry Lannier (Maurice Ronet). 

Harry is a figure who gives off mid-life crisis vibes; a cringeworthy dad with his prized sports car and top shirt buttons always undone. Harry, however, merely goes from being a figure of cringe to one of great suspicion from the accompaniment of Penelope (Jane Birkin), a girl he claims to be his daughter. Harry speaks of his daughter and interacts with her in a very intimate manner, commenting to others that she is pretty and telling her that her skin is smooth and that she smells nice. Both Jean-Paul and Marianne are surprised to discover their old friend even has a daughter. Penelope is apprehensive to talk about her background when Marianne asks her questions, while Harry simply tells Jean-Paul, “Her mother is simply an Englishwoman, you don’t know her”. Even the very scenario of a father and daughter going on a European road trip together is an unlikely one, with the film never making it clear if Harry is her Daddy or her “daddy”.

Throughout the film, Penelope wears short dresses and skirts (even to a funeral), although regardless of whether she is trying to provoke, she ignites a lust within a youth-chasing Jean-Paul. Even from their first meeting, Jean-Paul grabs her by the hand and asks, “How old are you?”, to which she responds mildly nervously, “Eighteen”. This eventually culminates in the two making love and, by extension, the dissolution of his relationship with Marianne. Delon and Schneider were real-life ex-fiancés, with the word through the grapevine being that he continued to be infatuated with her, with Delon being instrumental in getting Schneider cast in the film. Regardless, I’m sure their real-life background contributed to their on-screen chemistry and to the emotional weight of the gradual, undramatic breakdown of a relationship and the quiet acceptance of such within the film’s very slow build approach. 

Harry brings about Jean-Paul’s gradual emasculation, both through Harry’s subtle flirting with Marianne but more so through his low-key taunting of Jean-Paul in relation to his failed and abandoned career as a writer. Jean-Paul now works for an ad agency while Harry has no issue showing off the expected-to-be hit music records he is producing (he even has to rub it in his face that Mariane herself is a successful writer). After several days, the once cool Delon is now grumpy and carrying a bad posture. The glamorous film star now comes off as a loser. It is this aspect of The Swimming Pool which makes the film strangely comforting, that the rich and beautiful, our betters, are just as miserable as John Doe. On the surface, Jean-Paul has an incredible life, from a gorgeous girlfriend to a high-paying job that permits him to enjoy month-long summer holidays. Deep down, however, he is unhappy as he gave up on his ambitions of becoming a professional writer (with it even being revealed that he has attempted suicide in the past). Just like how social media in the modern day shows other people’s seemingly perfect and amazing lives, the swimming pool offers a distorted reflection that hides what lies beneath.

On a more humorous observation, The Swimming Pool showcases the dangers that arise when close friends start living with each other and/or spend prolonged periods of time together when travelling. The Swimming Pool takes it to the extreme, with the outcome being murder, as the tension between Harry and Jean-Paul reaches its boiling point (both Delon and Ronet had previously appeared alongside each other in Purple Noon (1960), to which both characters see a similar fate). The film’s final act delves into Columbo-like territory, as an inspector (Paul Crauchet), questions Jean-Paul and Marianne about the irregularities in the investigation of Harry’s death. These being Harry wearing a non-waterproof watch when he was found in the pool (which is itself foreshadowed earlier in the film when Harry asks for his watch immediately after coming out of the pool), and perhaps the biggest smoking gun, the clean, perspiration-free clothes lying next to the pool (like someone had taken clean clothes and just put them next to the pool, hmmm). It is this final act in which the picture increases the suspense as the possibility of Jean-Paul being outwitted by the inspector feels dangerously close. Was it an irrational decision for Jean-Paul to remove the clothes from Harry’s corpse and lay clean ones next to the pool, or should he have just left Harry as he was? I guess when you’ve just committed murder in a fit of jealous rage, you cease to think rationally.  

During Jean-Paul and Harry’s final confrontation by the pool, both men are dressed in corresponding white tops and blue jeans. The two look like mirror images of each other, a metaphor that Jean-Paul’s interest in Penelope is partly an expression of Harry’s taboo desire for his own daughter. Likewise, when Jean-Paul is dunking Harry beneath the water, it echoes the myth of Narcissus, in which a young mortal, in love with his own beauty, drowns while trying to possess his reflection. Just like The Swimmer before it, The Swimming Pool takes its setting to its ultimate metaphorical height. The pool only reveals its true depth once you look beneath the surface.

Dragnet Girl [非常線の女/ Hijōsen no Onna] (1933)

One Last Job

***This Review Contains Spoilers***

Dragnet Girl (非常線の女, Hijōsen no Onna) was Yasujiro Ozu’s final foray into the gangster genre, and appropriately so, as the picture is deeply embellished in not only the aesthetics of the genre, but also the tropes. Dragnet Girl captures the pulpy world of James Cagney and Edward G. Robinson, but unlike the American pictures of the time, it is a silent film. It is this, alongside the additional combination of German expressionism and traditional Japanese iconography, which creates a unique hybrid of a film. By this point in his filmography, those famous Ozu still frames are well in use, and needless to say, the man knows how to compose a shot that sticks in your mind long after watching (with Dragnet Girl in particular being very keen on layered, deep focus shots looking through glass).

One of the film’s major recurring motifs is the striking image of several dangling, gymnastic rings with the silhouette of a boxer adorning the wall and containing the words (in English), “The manly art of self-defence”. This is one of several examples in the film showcasing the Japanese use of English as a cosmopolitan signifier. Later in the film, a pool hall is showcased, in which the rules of the game are printed on the wall in large English text (as well as the early Ozu motif of prominently featuring Hollywood movie posters in the background). In a more subtle use of English as a cosmopolitan signifier, the office featured in the film has an array of typists working on typewriters; however, there were no Japanese-language typewriters akin to the standard QWERTY Western typewriter in 1933 (rather, Japanese typewriters of the time were large, cumbersome machines), suggesting that this company provides translation services.

Correspondingly, although Dragnet Girl is a Japanese gangster film, the traditional Japanese gangster of the Yakuza are nowhere to be seen. Rather, Dragnet Girl focuses on a subculture known as Mobo (Modern Boy) and Moga (Modern Girl), a youth movement which rejected traditional societal values and embraced Westernised clothing, jazz music, and a liberated, urban lifestyle (prevalent during Japan’s Taishō and early Shōwa periods). Likewise, the plot of Dragnet Girl is built on tropes commonly seen in various Hollywood gangster pictures. Kazuko (Sumiko Mizukubo) becomes concerned that her younger brother Hiroshi (Kōji Mitsui) is skipping school and hanging out with local gangsters. To combat this, she approaches head gangster Joji (Joji Oka), whom her brother respects and admires, to tell her brother to straighten himself out. Joji obliges and tells the youngling to leave the world behind (Hiroshi himself is very unconvincing as a gangster, coming off as a larper). This recognition that the gangster ultimately knows what they do isn’t right and will stop others (the innocent and naïve in particular) from entering the world is seen in later Hollywood films, such as Kid Galahad or the ending of Angels With Dirty Faces.

Sumiko Mizukubo perfectly sells the role of Kazuko with her homely, down-to-earth, innocent demeanour. With no parents present or even mentioned, Kazuko is a mother figure to her brother and a youth who has been forced into the role of a hardworking adult. On the opposite end of the spectrum, however, is Joji’s girlfriend and self-described delinquent Tokiko (Kinuyo Tanaka). Tokiko is on an equal footing with her male gangster peers and is treated like one of the guys. Likewise, in stark contrast to the innocence of Mizukubo, Tanaka is a true, glamorous movie star in the Hollywood form (and boasting an impressive wardrobe in this picture).

Both Joji and Tokiko, however, find themselves questioning their paths in life following their encounters with Kazuko. They both fall for her charm, with Tokiko stating, “I’ve started to feel more domesticated since I met her”, and quickly develops a desire to start knitting socks for Joji. This trope itself, of the otherwise cold and calculating gangster revealing a softer, more affectionate side due to the influence of an innocent, girl-next-door, is seen in later films such as The Roaring Twenties and High Sierra (and Ozu’s earlier gangster picture Walk Cheerfully). Joji and Tokiko decide they will go straight and begin their trad lifestyle, but not before engaging in that other timeless trope of doing “one last job”. If you know anything about gangster pictures, the “one last job” never quite goes to plan.

In many subtle ways, Dragnet Girl presents the gangster lifestyle as a cowardly way of life. Joji, a former boxer, is pursued by a trainer at the gym to return to fighting, which he rejects. This, coupled with the aforementioned recurring image of the boxer with the words “The manly art of self-defence”, suggests that the path of a fighter is more noble than that of a gangster. While the film shows the glamour that comes with the lifestyle, just like Cagney in The Public Enemy or Robinson in Little Ceaser, in the end, it all comes crashing down. Likewise, many may read into the film that the purification of Joji and Tokiko comes in the form of the only character throughout who wears traditional Japanese clothes, suggesting a traditional antidote to the perverted import of Western malaise. Although this is a reading I don’t buy into, as by all accounts, Ozu himself makes it no secret himself to be a fan of western culture in the form of Hollywood movies, with this picture, concluding his trilogy of Hollywood-inspired gangster movies, and in my view, some of the most underrated work of his long career.

That Night’s Wife [その夜の妻/Sono Yo no Tsuma] (1930)

Darkest Before Dawn

***This Review Contains Spoilers***

Aeons before the likes of Quentin Tarantino, Kevin Smith or Edgar Wright, Yasujiro Ozu may be one of the earliest examples of a director to showcase his film buff credentials through his own work. The director’s early films, including his crime dramas and student comedies, are adorned with love for American films and frequently featured posters of Hollywood movies garnishing the walls. This expression of love for American film permeates That Night’s Wife. The film is almost entirely devoid of any Japanese iconography (with the one major exception being the titular wife in her kimono attire), even down to the point that there is no act of shoe removal when entering a home. From tall buildings with Greek pillars, men in fedoras, candlestick telephones, noir shadows or that Fritz Lang-esque shot of a handprint on the glass, this mixture of Americana and German expressionism creates an infectious pulp world. It’s this unabashed display of cinephilia which really makes me love Ozu’s crime trilogy alongside the pictures Walk Cheerfully and Dragnet Girl.

The premise of That Night’s Wife is very simple but highly effective. A father, Shuji Hashizume (Tokihiko Okada), robs an office to pay the medical expenses for his terminally ill daughter. The loving father, however, is not very convincing as a master criminal, appearing rather awkward as a bandana covers his visibly nervous face. This is further compounded by the sheer size of the urban space, the towering architecture and the army of police officers, all dwarfing the individual as he tries to evade the law after committing his crime. Rather, Shuji is an effete artist whose family of three appear to live in a bohemian, artist’s studio, covered in the aforementioned movie posters, travel souvenirs, and an abundance of paint cans scattered throughout, implying that Shuji is a starving painter (a graphic designer perhaps?).

Much of the runtime inside the apartment itself plays out in a series of shifting power dynamics and mind games (like a miniaturised version of the movie Sleuth), between the married couple and a taxi driver who turns out to be an undercover cop (Tōgō Yamamoto), most memorably during a sleep standoff between the wife (Emiko Yagumo) and the cop. The husband and wife are co-protagonists in the picture, in which the loyal wife ardently remains by her husband’s side despite objecting to his decision to steal money. There is a tender and intimate simplicity in watching a mother trying to keep this domestic situation together and caring for her ill child; after all, nobody does domesticity like Ozu.

That’s Night’s Wife is a film of simple moral dilemmas. The parents’ love for a child supersedes all else as a father willing to sacrifice himself and his future to ensure the survival of his daughter. He does make a run for it when the opportunity arises, but only for his conscience forcing him to return to the apartment and turn himself in (“I must obey the law and return my debt to society”). The cop, on the other hand, is a calm and compassionate guardian deeply moved by the family’s predicament but also knowing that the law must be served. – Is a man justified to steal money and hold others at gunpoint to save the life of his own kin because he can’t afford healthcare?

What the film doesn’t have in meaning primed to be deeply intellectualised, That Night’s Wife is a film buried in symbolism and visual metaphor. From the fish skeleton on a plate as a backdrop in the opening titles (an image of hunger, death and desperation), the pessimistic image of a flower dying in a half-empty glass of water (or is the glass half full?), to the recurring motif of the floppy doll on a toy swing (a visual representation of the daughter’s vulnerability?). But perhaps the most significant symbolism of all is the film’s passing of time. Set over the course of a single night, the film concludes with the daughter having survived her illness, after the sun has risen following a very long, tiring and difficult night. It’s always darkest before dawn.

3-Iron [빈집/Binjip] (2004)

A Little Less Conversation…

***This Review Contains Spoilers***

Is it harder to construct a film with little or no dialogue compared to the average parlance-filled production? While the general rule of filmmaking is “show, don’t tell”, dialogue is still an important tool for revealing character motivations, relationships, plot information, themes, emotional states, etc. Since the majority of movies in existence (barring silent pictures) are comprised of characters speaking to each other, to watch a movie with this tool stripped out, it really makes you consider all that goes into the art of storytelling through only visual means. 3-Iron (Binjip) is one of several productions in which (the late) director Kim Ki-duk excels at this very feat. 

Not a single word is spoken by the two leads in 3-Iron (almost), yet the film still creates compelling characters through only visual means. The film’s initially unnamed young protagonist (Jae Hee) (later revealed to be called Tae-Suk) is a drifter who enters and lives in people’s homes while they are on vacation. However, he is likely not a poor man. He is a well-groomed, pretty boy with an expensive motorcycle and a passion for golf (hence 3-Iron), suggesting that perhaps wealth aids this dangerous and unethical hobby of his.

This pastime is aided by his technical know-how. He can identify when no one is home by placing restaurant flyers on the doors of homes, and when the flyer hasn’t been taken down after a period of time, he picks the door lock and makes his way in (as well as listening to the messages on the answering machines inside). From there, he treats the dwelling like his own home (watching TV, taking a bath, self-pleasuring himself in bed). Tae-suk, however, is not a thief (at least not in the traditional sense). He keeps the homes he has broken into clean, does the laundry, waters plants and even fixes broken electronics, thus helping create empathy from the viewer. This, however, doesn’t undo the ethical dimension of his actions. In much of the world, the protection of private property is held as sacrosanct and for good reason. To have someone break into your house feels incredibly violatory and people even end up moving house because of it. Why does Tae-suk partake in this hobby? Is he simply a thrill seeker and/or mentally unwell (especially since he remains mute) or a perverted voyeurist (his collection of selfies taken alongside family portraits would suggest so)?

These sequences of Tae-suk scouting and then breaking into people’s homes feel very reminiscent of French filmmaker Jean-Pierre Melville. In particular, his seminal film Le Samouraï (1967), which, like 3-Iron, depicts lengthy dialogue-free sequences in which illegal activity is perpetrated in meticulous detail but with a sense of calm and harmony. From the quiet, empty scenes of the suburban streets of Seoul to the film’s wide showcase of Korean home design, 3-Iron has a sense of comforting domesticity. Likewise, the film even acts as a nostalgic representation of the pre-Internet of Things world with its array of early 2000’s tech. Although the most memorable filming location present in the film is Seoul’s famous Bukchon Hanok Village, a residential area comprised of picturesque traditional Korean houses known as Hanok. Having been there myself in 2025, I can say there is no way that the officials monitoring visitors would allow anyone to attach flyers to the doors nowadays (although I don’t know if that would have been the case either in 2004).

Tae-suk’s blurred world of fantasy vs reality comes to a head when he finds out he is not alone in the house of a wealthy businessman, when he meets his abused and black-eyed laden wife (Lee Seung-yun). Like Tae-suk, she is also mute but is able to portray a sense of torment through purely visual means. Not fearing Tae-suk, the two form a bond and leave the house together to escape her abusive marriage, all while, as a viewer, I ask myself if they will ever actually break their silence. The law, however, eventually catches up to the two delinquents, with Tae-suk thrown in prison and the wife returned to her abusive husband. 

Depending on how you choose to interpret the final act of 3-Iron, Tae-suk may have died during his incarceration and became a literal ghost (as indicated later by his weight scale reading of “0”), or through the stealth manovers he learnt during this period (to avoid the regular beatings of a corrupt officer), has escaped from prison and has had a metaphorical transformation into a ghost. The following portion of the film plays out like a semi-horror film in which, through a series of voyeuristic point-of-view shots (even feeling quite Michael Myers-esque), he gets revenge on a corrupt police officer who wronged him, with the 3-Iron and some golf balls as his weapon of choice.

Tae-suk returns to the house of the abused woman, where the blurring of fantasy and reality reaches its zenith. Tae-suk remains in the house in view of the wife, while the husband is unaware of his presence. The woman smiles for the first time and utters her only line in the movie, “I love you”. The husband thinks the line is directed at him, but it’s actually to Tae-suk standing behind him. All three characters are now living a lie, yet for perhaps the first time in the film, all three appear content. “It’s hard to tell the world we live in is either a reality or a dream”.